How to Face Your Fears in a Campaign Based on Stephen King's IT

Stephen King’s IT is a masterclass in psychological horror, blending supernatural elements with the terrifying realities of growing up. The novel’s eerie atmosphere, complex characters, and the ominous presence of Pennywise the Dancing Clown have made it a beloved and horrifying tale for generations. Here's a guide to creating a campaign inspired by IT—one that will have your players gripping their dice and jumping at shadows.

Understand the Core Themes of IT

Childhood vs. Adulthood: The characters in IT face a battle between the innocence and courage of childhood and the fear and conformity of adulthood. A campaign could explore this transition, using a group of young protagonists who eventually become adults, confronting the horrors of their past.

Fear: At the core of the story is the idea of fear. Pennywise preys on the characters' individual fears, using them to manifest and become stronger. A successful campaign should delve deep into the personal fears of the players and turn them into physical or psychological threats.

Group Dynamics and Friendship: The strength of the group lies in its bonds of friendship, especially when facing the unexplainable. A campaign built on this theme will rely heavily on teamwork and encourage the players to develop meaningful relationships with one another.

The Supernatural and the Unseen: The eerie, looming presence of IT is always just out of sight, creating an atmosphere of paranoia. Use this element in your campaign to keep players on edge and unsure whether what they’re seeing is real or part of their imagination.

Setting the Stage: A Town Full of Secrets

The setting is key to recreating the oppressive, dread-filled atmosphere of IT. Derry, the fictional town where much of the novel takes place, is a character in its own right. To capture that essence, consider the following:

Small Town with a Dark History: Your campaign should be set in a seemingly idyllic town that hides its dark secrets. Maybe it's a quiet community that has always seemed “normal” to outsiders but has a history of disappearances, bizarre occurrences, and unsettling myths that have been covered up over the years.

Time Period and Shifting Realities: IT shifts between the 1950s and the 1980s, creating a sense of nostalgia, loss, and the passing of time. A similar approach can be applied to your campaign, with the players either playing characters who grew up in the town or who return as adults to face their fears.

The Geography of Fear: Just like Derry, your town should have places where the supernatural thrives. Abandoned buildings, sewer systems, old forests, and dark corners of the town all offer perfect spots for your players to uncover secrets or encounter the horrors lurking within.

Create Your Own Pennywise: The Villain

In IT, Pennywise the Clown is the physical manifestation of the malevolent force that haunts Derry. But Pennywise is more than just a clown; he is the embodiment of fear itself. While you don't have to replicate Pennywise exactly, here’s how to create a similar antagonist:

The Entity: IT isn't just a clown—it’s a shape-shifting entity that feeds off the fear of children. For your campaign, create an ancient and evil entity that can take various forms, from a grotesque monster to an innocuous object that becomes terrifying when viewed in the right light. The key is that it must be versatile, unpredictable, and always lurking in the background.

Psychological Horror: The true horror of IT lies in its ability to manipulate and control its victims by exploiting their deepest fears. In your campaign, make sure that the villain isn’t just a physical threat but also an emotional and psychological one. Whether it’s through dreams, hallucinations, or manipulations, the entity should constantly remind your players that they can’t escape their fear.

The Clown or Symbolic Figure: Whether it’s a clown or some other horrifying form, give your villain a specific shape or motif. This gives players something recognizable to fear, while still allowing the entity to transform and manipulate its form.

OR… here’s a link to purchase our own IT-like creation, The Harbinger of Laughter.

Fear and the Personal Struggles of Characters

Each character in IT has a specific fear that IT exploits, turning their greatest vulnerabilities into weapons of terror. Here’s how to integrate personal fears into your campaign:

Personal Fears as Mechanics: Encourage your players to come up with a deep personal fear—whether it’s spiders, the dark, isolation, or even something abstract like failure or betrayal. Integrate these fears into the game, forcing the characters to face them as the story progresses. You can use these fears as triggers for in-game events or as part of an encounter’s climax.

Flashbacks to Childhood: To fully embrace the IT vibe, include flashbacks to when the characters were younger, encountering the same entity. These flashbacks should reveal clues about the entity’s nature, as well as challenges that the characters must overcome in the present day.

Group Bonds and Personal Growth: Like the Losers’ Club in IT, your characters will have to rely on each other to defeat the entity. Encourage your players to build deep bonds with one another. This could involve creating shared histories or personal connections that go beyond typical adventuring camaraderie.

Creating Suspense and Atmosphere

To truly capture the unnerving, suspenseful feeling of IT, you need to keep the tension high and the atmosphere thick with dread. Here are some techniques for building that:

Slow Burn: Don’t rush the horror. Start with subtle, unsettling events—whispers, shadows, strange occurrences—and gradually build to more intense scenes. The horror should grow with every encounter, forcing the players to question whether what they’re experiencing is real.

Unpredictable Threats: Keep the players on their toes by making the entity unpredictable. It can appear when least expected, shifting its appearance and terrorizing the characters in new ways. This forces players to confront their own uncertainty and paranoia.

Cliffhanger Moments: Like Stephen King’s mastery of building suspense, include moments that leave the players with questions that won’t be answered immediately. Perhaps they see a figure in the distance or hear a chilling laugh that echoes through the town. These small, unnerving moments will keep your players hooked.

Ending the Campaign: Confrontation and Growth

The final showdown with IT in the novel is a powerful, emotional moment, filled with both horror and triumph. Your campaign’s conclusion should build toward an epic confrontation that involves more than just physical battles.

A Battle of Wills: To capture the essence of the final confrontation, create a scenario where the players must face their fears head-on. Perhaps they must enter the heart of the entity’s domain, where reality bends and the laws of physics no longer apply.

Emotional Resolution: Whether they succeed or fail, the characters should come away from the experience with emotional growth. The horror of IT has scarred them, but through the process of facing their fears, they should have learned something about themselves and each other.

Final Thoughts

Creating a campaign based on Stephen King’s IT is an opportunity to craft a rich, terrifying adventure that explores themes of fear, friendship, and the passage of time. By focusing on building a town steeped in dark secrets, crafting a versatile and menacing villain, and weaving in personal fears and emotional growth, you can create a truly unforgettable experience for your players. Just remember—horror works best when it’s rooted in the characters’ fears, so don’t hold back in exploring the depths of their nightmares!

Are you ready to step into the world of IT and confront your own fears? Grab your dice, gather your friends, and prepare to face the darkness.

Pick up The Harbinger of Laughter here to get your IT-inspired game off and running.